Saved buildings
save our heritage organisation logo

Yahoo  MSN  Google

SOHO Files Suit in Del Mar to Stop Demolition

SOHO filed a Petition for Writ of Mandamus in the San Diego Superior Court (Case No. GIC 839854) on December 9, 2004, challenging the City of Del Mar's approval of the demolition of the historic Batchelder House. An Environmental Impact Report that was prepared for the project illustrated feasible alternatives to demolition, and the suit points out that under mandates of the California Environmental Quality Act such alternatives preclude approval of demolition.

The project applicant wishes to divide the Del Mar parcel into two lots and build two new single family homes. Ironically, the new homes are proposed to mimic the Craftsman style architecture of the existing house.

Executive Director Bruce Coons explained that "as a compromise, one alternative is to move the Batchelder House onto one side of the lot, allowing a second home to be built on the newly created second lot." The goal of having two single-family homes on two lots would then be accomplished without the loss of an important historic resource. Famed architect Richard Requa built the Batchelder House in 1924.

Coons stated further that "the EIR process worked just as it should, confirming the historic significance of the Batchelder House and analyzing the feasible alternatives to demolition. The City, however erroneously claimed that preserving the home would be a financial hardship and that HABS documentation would reduce the impact of the demolition to a level "below significance" as reasons for approving the demolition. In other words, draw it, photograph it, and the demolition is not an impact to the resource. These are of course ridiculous assertions and this forced us to take action so it cannot happen in the future."

The suit seeks a peremptory writ ordering the City of Del Mar to set aside its approval of demolition because there are feasible alternatives.

2005 - Volume 36, Issue 1


VIEW digital online version

Preservation Wins and Winners

Happy New Year!

The Ranch House at Warner's

Progress Report on Red Roost/Red Rest

Balboa Theatre

SOHO Files Suit in Del Mar to Stop Demolition

2004 Historical Landmarks

Mission Hills Heritage

SOHO would like to extend appreciation

In Memoriam

Adobe Chapel of the Immaculate Conception

Our Wish List for the Adobe Chapel

Thank You's

Adobe Chapel Welcomes the Old Town Community

An Exciting Opportunity for Volunteers

Bringing History Alive at the Whaley House

Who is the Chinese Gardener at the Whaley House?

Cheap San Diego Housing

Resource Directory (33-page pdf)

Four Treatment Approaches

Yeah, yeah, yeah - Modernism Rocks!

Some Like It Preserved

People In Preservation

Getting to Know Your SOHO Staff

Houses Available, Must be Moved

Notice: Date Moved for SOHO Board Directors Meetings

Notice to all Members with email

Found San Diego

Strength in Numbers

Lost San Diego

VIEW digital online version

DOWNLOAD full magazine as pdf (4.3mb)


2476 San Diego Avenue · San Diego CA 92110 · Phone (619) 297-9327
Home | Contact